Opens in a new tab

Liquidator Admits Proof of Debt of Related Companies

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: May 24, 2020
Page Content
Page Content

A recent case in the Federal Court of Australia (Federal Court) has shed light on the admissibility of a proof of debt by a liquidator regarding related companies.

In the case of Barnden (Liquidator), in the matter of Masonry Works Pty Limited (in liquidation) [2020] FCA 575, the Federal Court considered the performance of a liquidator’s duties in a quasi-judicial capacity to determine the true liabilities of a company.

Background

Andrew Barnden was the sole liquidator of both Masonry Works Pty Ltd (in liq) (Company) and Masonry Profiles Pty Ltd (in liq) (Profiles). The liquidator made an application to lodge a proof of debt of Profiles which concerned a discrepancy of the recorded amounts of a loan paid by Profiles to the Company. The contention was whether or not Mr Barnden as liquidator of both companies, could admit to proof in the liquidation of a claim by one company against the other company.

Decision

The application was granted pursuant to the power in s 90-15 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule which justifies a liquidator in accepting a proof of debt (In the matter of Daily Planet Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) [2019] VSC 265). The Court stated that Mr Barnden was obliged to assess Profile’s proof of debt in his capacity as a liquidator of the company, in a quasi-judicial capacity.

The liquidator was entitled to protection of the Court, recognizing that the liquidator had faithfully performed his duties, conducting thorough investigations of the incomplete and conflicting evidence to examine the discrepancy of the loan amount.

The Court, therefore, allowed the proof of debt in the liquidation of the company to be admitted.

 

Interested in learning more on Insolvency & Reconstruction? 

Click our recent articles below to find out more:

Broad Powers and Blurred Lines: The Court’s Power to Approve Invalidly Appointed Liquidators

Bankruptcy 101: Voidable Transactions

How to Annul your Bankruptcy

If you have any questions regarding a liquidator’s capacity in assessing finances of a company in liquidation, please contact Mr Stipe Vuleta of our Litigation & Restructuring Team of 6188 3600.

Related articles

From Weak Evidence to Adverse Costs

A recent decision handed down by the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory (ACTSC) has shed light on the...

Read more about From Weak Evidence to Adverse Costs

Debt Recovery in the Local Court of New South Wales – Part 3 of 4

Part 3: Garnishee Orders There are two main types of Garnishee Orders which are issued in the Local Court. These...

Read more about Debt Recovery in the Local Court of New South Wales – Part 3 of 4

Priority of Caveatable Interests

If you are a secured creditor of a debtor, you may be able to lodge a caveat over the debtor's...

Read more about Priority of Caveatable Interests

Creditor-Defeating Dispositions

A creditor-defeating disposition occurs when a company, who is being wound up, transfers property or other high value assets for...

Read more about Creditor-Defeating Dispositions