Opens in a new tab

“It’s not clear that I have to pay your fees – and you drafted the contract!”

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: September 29, 2020
Page Content
Page Content

In the decision of J P Morgan Australia Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 3, the Court considered a case where a client appointed an investment banker to advise on takeovers and mergers.

 

The contract was formed by an engagement letter from the banker being accepted by the client. The engagement letter entitled the banker to various fees based on different events, offers and payments.

 

Following a “bidding war” the client became a wholly-owned subsidiary of a purchaser.

 

Following the transaction, the banker issued an invoice for $50m. The client objected to it and paid only $20m. The banker sued for remaining $30m, lost at first instance and appealed.

 

Critical was whether payment for a pre-bid stake in the client was “in connection with” the eventually accepted offer. If it was, then the banker was entitled to charge a higher fee than if it was not.

 

The Court found that matters “in connection with” an offer for the purposes of the particular engagement could only arise after the relevant request, and not before. As the payment for a pre-bid stake was before the suitable offer, this caused difficulty for the banker.

 

The Court took some support for its view from the doctrine of contra proferentem. The banker drafted the term, it gave rise to a large fee, and if it was ambiguous, then the banker had no claim to have those doubts resolved in its favour.

 

The banker’s appeal and the client were not required to pay the particular fee claimed.

If you have any questions or concerns, contact James d’Apice on 02 6188 3600.

Related articles

When Will Legal Costs Be Too High, To Be Worthwhile?

In the recent decision of the Supreme Court of NSW, Balzola v Passas (No 2) [2020] NSWSC 1200, a plaintiff sued two...

Read more about When Will Legal Costs Be Too High, To Be Worthwhile?

“I’ll repay the funds you invested. Trust me!”: Baxter Global Investments Pty Ltd (ACN 159 246 670) v Marco [2020] NSWSC 1293

Two plaintiffs invested money with the first defendant for a fixed term having signed various documents titled “Declaration of Trust”....

Read more about “I’ll repay the funds you invested. Trust me!”: Baxter Global Investments Pty Ltd (ACN 159 246 670) v Marco [2020] NSWSC 1293

So I Can’t Blame My Secretary?!

In Rodney v Stricke (No 2) [2020] NSWSC 1126  costs were ordered against a solicitor personally for administration related delays. A solicitor...

Read more about So I Can’t Blame My Secretary?!

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

“Let Me Go Get The Company’s Money!”

In the recent decision of Lotus Property Fund No 8 Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1349 the Court considered an application...

Read more about “Let Me Go Get The Company’s Money!”