Opens in a new tab

“Let Me Go Get The Company’s Money!”

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: October 14, 2020
Legal Topics
Litigation & Dispute Resolution
Page Content
Page Content

In the recent decision of Lotus Property Fund No 8 Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1349 the Court considered an application by a former director to bring a derivative action on behalf of a company. That is, speaking loosely, the former director wanted to “stand in the shoes” of the company to sue another party, because the company wasn’t going to do so itself.

Around $100 million was paid following the development of a site in Sydney. The company was the trustee of a trust that stood to receive some of those proceeds.

The plaintiff – who was a former director of the company – had the benefit of a “side deed” which would see a related entity of his benefit if the company received a greater share of the sale proceeds. The various relationships between the relevant parties had some complexity such that the Court saw fit to prepare two diagrams to describe them.

Some of the sale proceeds were distributed, or were to be distributed, in a way that concerned the plaintiff.

The plaintiff sought the Court’s leave to bring a claim on behalf of the company that the company should receive a greater share of the sale proceeds. It was clear to all that the company was not going to bring the claim itself.

The Court found the application was brought in good faith, with the plaintiff’s motivation being to seek a proper distribution of funds for the benefit of the company.

The “relatively low” threshold of whether there was a serious question to be tried was met.

The purpose of the plaintiff bringing the proceedings – for the company to take a greater share of sale proceeds, or information that would enable it to do that – was found to be in the company’s best interests. This finding was made despite the uncertainties about the plaintiff’s prospects in any litigation, or the potential defendant’s ability to pay.

The plaintiff was found to have no conflict of interest with the company, and so was granted leave to proceed, notwithstanding the absence of notice.

This case is an illustration of how, even if a company does not want to bring proceedings itself, an interested party can seek the Court’s help to “stand in the shoes” of the company and bring proceedings anyway.

 

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Chamberlains and talk to our dispute resolution team today.

 

Interested in learning more on Litigation & Dispute Resolution?

Click our recent articles below to find out more:

Exposure to penalties under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW)

Some implications for costs under the CPA 2005 (NSW)

Witnessing Documents and Giving Evidence by AVL

If you have any questions or concerns, contact James d’Apice on 02 9264 9111

Related articles

“It’s not clear that I have to pay your fees – and you drafted the contract!”

In the decision of J P Morgan Australia Ltd v Consolidated Minerals Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 3, the Court considered a case...

Read more about “It’s not clear that I have to pay your fees – and you drafted the contract!”

So I Can’t Blame My Secretary?!

In Rodney v Stricke (No 2) [2020] NSWSC 1126  costs were ordered against a solicitor personally for administration related delays. A solicitor...

Read more about So I Can’t Blame My Secretary?!

How to Deal With Your Business Breakup

Have you considered how your business will move forward in the event that you or your business partner have a...

Read more about How to Deal With Your Business Breakup

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

“I should’ve accepted that offer!”

Lawyers often send settlement offers when dealing with disputes. These are sometimes in the form of "Calderbank" offers, named for...

Read more about “I should’ve accepted that offer!”