Opens in a new tab

Bankruptcy Notices: Enforcement Mechanism or an Abuse of Process?

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: November 25, 2020
Page Content
Page Content

In the matter of Mariconte v Nobarani [2020] FCA 1485, the Federal Court of Australia revisited the Court’s inherent power to set aside bankruptcy notices due to an abuse of process and cautioned against the use of bankruptcy notices as a debt collection method.

The proceedings arose from a six year dispute regarding the administration of a deceased estate. The Applicant alleged that the Respondent impermissibly issued the Bankruptcy Notice as a debt collection mechanism to recover a restitution judgment issued in prior proceedings. The Respondent tactically chose to claim the debt through a bankruptcy notice rather than applying for an ‘obvious order’ for the sale of the Applicant’s property which had been previously offered by the Supreme Court. This decision was made despite Parker J’s suggestions that issuing a bankruptcy notice was unlikely to be the ‘proper way for Mr Nobarani to proceed. The Respondent justified their decision on the basis that they had been entitled to payment for 8 months and believed that receiving the proceeds of sale through a sale order could result in liability as a recipient of disputed trust property or an unfair preference claim.

Although the Applicant had failed to pay or challenge the restitution judgment, the Court determined  that it was improper to use bankruptcy proceedings as an enforcement action when other avenues are available. The Court was critical of the Respondent’s failure to make any attempts to enforce the Restitution Judgment or to even make a demand for payment. Interestingly, the Court also held that evaluation of an abuse of process was not impacted by the fact that the Applicant had been served in an aggressive and ‘less than ideal’ manner.

This case serves as an important reminder that parties must strongly consider their purpose in issuing bankruptcy notices and ensure that other avenues of enforcement are contemplated first. Ultimately, the categories of conduct or circumstances for an abuse of process will remain open and responsive to contemporary values of justice. On this occasion, the Court has re-affirmed that the use of a bankruptcy notice to pressure debtors to pay a debt, rather than to invoke the Court’s jurisdiction regarding insolvency, is improper.

 

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Chamberlains and talk to one of our insolvency lawyers today.

 

Interested in learning more on Insolvency & Reconstruction? 

Click our recent articles below to find out more:

If you have any questions about bankruptcy notices, contact Stipe Vuleta of our Insolvency and Reconstruction team on 02 6188 3600

Related articles

Bankruptcy FAQ’s (Part Three)

Implications of Bankruptcy 3.1 How do I declare bankruptcy? Essentially, there are two ways to declare bankruptcy, either voluntarily or...

Read more about Bankruptcy FAQ’s (Part Three)

Chamberlains Lawcast: Thriving (or not) Post COVID-19

In today's episode, Chamberlains' Managing Director, Stipe Vuleta, is again joined by Condon Advisory's Managing Principal Schon Condon , Associate...

Read more about Chamberlains Lawcast: Thriving (or not) Post COVID-19

Principles To Remember When Interpreting Terms Of Commercial Contracts

As summarised by the High Court with respect to the interpretation of contracts in Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd (2014)...

Read more about Principles To Remember When Interpreting Terms Of Commercial Contracts

Personal Bankruptcy Threshold Permanently Set to $10,000

Attorney-General Christian Porter today announced that Australia’s personal bankruptcy threshold will be set at $10,000. The threshold was temporarily lifted...

Read more about Personal Bankruptcy Threshold Permanently Set to $10,000