Opens in a new tab

A valid reason for dismissal can still be procedurally unfair

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: April 14, 2022
Legal Topics
Employment & Workplace Law
Page Content
Page Content

In a recent decision the Fair Work Commission has reminded employers that whilst they may have a valid reason for terminating an employee, the termination process undertaken by the employer must follow procedural fairness.

In Mr Simon Ronchi v Johns Lyng Group [2022] FWC 326, Mr Ronchi was dismissed from his employment for sending inappropriate messages, making inappropriate social media posts, promoting his own business and neglecting his duties during work hours.

Among other unprofessional conduct which included sending anonymous text messages to his manager, Mr Ronchi sent an email from his Johns Lyng Group work email address to three business partners, promoting a demolition company registered in his name stating that John Lyng Group had partnered with his company as its preferred contractor.

The Commission found that Mr Ronchi’s conduct was serious and intended to cause harm rendering it highly likely to cause damage to the employee and employer relationship. As such, the Commission deemed that the dismissal of Mr Ronchi’s was a proportionate response to his disregard for his express contractual duties.

However, although Mr Ronchi’s conduct was found to be ‘wilful and inconsistent with obligations to his employer’, the Commission simultaneously noted that the dismissal was procedurally unfair due to John Lyng Group’s failure to afford Mr Ronchi an opportunity to consider the allegations and evidence before a decision was made to terminate his employment. In this regard, Commissioner Yilmaz stated:

“Given the serious nature of the allegations and the breadth of evidence against Mr Ronchi, an opportunity to digest the allegations and show cause why he should not be dismissed would have been a more appropriate and fair dismissal process.”

In light of this, Mr Ronchi was awarded an amount of $1,635 being 1 weeks’ compensation.

Key Take Aways

  • Employers should always remember to exercise care and diligence when undertaking steps to terminate an employment relationship.
  • The seriousness of an employee’s conduct, or performance, will not prove to be sufficient justification for a lack of procedural fairness.
  • Irrespective of whether there are valid grounds for dismissal, failure to adhere to adequate processes and procedures can potentially result in undesired outcomes such as reinstatement of the employee or an award of compensation to the employee.

 

Contact the Workplace Law Team at Chamberlains Law Firm for any questions and concerns.

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Antonia Tahhan of our Workplace Law Team on 02 9264 9111

Related articles

Employment & Workplace Law

Enterprise Agreement – Your Business’s Holy Grail

As your business expands, so does your workplace obligations. With a myriad of legislation, regulations and industrial instruments governing employee...

Read more about Enterprise Agreement – Your Business’s Holy Grail

Employment & Workplace Law

Making sure your female employees have correctly fitting PPE is a WHS issue

“PPE is still made for a 6ft 3in male rugby player” Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is anything used or worn...

Read more about Making sure your female employees have correctly fitting PPE is a WHS issue

Employment & Workplace Law

Excessive personal texting at work – A valid ground for termination

Most employers understand that personal situations or emergencies may occur during work hours that an employee may be required to...

Read more about Excessive personal texting at work – A valid ground for termination

Employment & Workplace Law

Dismissal versus Demotion: Does a pay cut give rise to a constructive dismissal?

With ample industrial instruments, policies and procedures governing the workplace, employers across the nation are tasked with navigating a minefield...

Read more about Dismissal versus Demotion: Does a pay cut give rise to a constructive dismissal?