Opens in a new tab

Historical Abuse – What is the ‘Ellis Defence’?

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: August 31, 2022 Updated: November 21, 2025
Legal Topics
Abuse Compensation Claims
Page Content
Page Content

The ‘Ellis Defence’’ was commonly used by those associated with historical child abuse claims, but what does it mean?

Court Proceedings

The Ellis Defence arose in the case of Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Archdiocese of Sydney v Ellis & Anor [2007] NSWCA 117 (“the Ellis Case”).

In this case, Mr Ellis brought a claim against the Roman Catholic Church for the Archdiocese of Sydney (“the Diocese”) on the basis that he had suffered historic sexual abuse.

Why the Defence Succeeded

The Diocese argued that while all the property of the Church was held by the trustees in each diocese, who were incorporated under 1936 NSW legislation, those trustees were not responsible for the conduct of the clergy and there was no legal entity available to be sued in respect of the misconduct of the clergy themselves.

The Court upheld the Diocese’s argument and Mr Ellis was ultimately denied the opportunity to have his case determined on its merits as it was found there was no proper defendant to sue.

Royal Commission Scrutiny and Law Reform

Mr Ellis’ case was scrutinised in the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse.

In 2018, law reform was made across Australia to protect the victims of institutionalised child sexual abuse. Legislation was enacted that forced unincorporated organisations—including religious institutions—to nominate a legal entity with sufficient assets for child abuse survivors to sue.

In passing legislation of this nature in Victoria, Daniel Andrews noted at the time that the legislation was designed to:

“Quash an unfair loophole preventing child abuse survivors from suing some organisations for their abuse.”

The End of the Ellis Defence

The demise of the Ellis defence saw a significant step in offering greater protection to the most vulnerable people in Australia and meant the Church were no longer allowed to hide behind the law.

Need Help?

If you or someone you know has been affected by historic sexual abuse, please reach out to Chamberlains Law Firm for abuse compensation claims.

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Director Jon May of our Personal Injury Team on 02 6188 3600

Related articles

Empty classroom with wooden desks and metal-framed chairs arranged in rows on a polished wooden floor, illuminated by natural sunlight streaming through large windows — representing education, learning spaces, and academic environments.

Abuse Compensation Claims

Your Story Matters: Witnesses Sought in Historical Abuse Case Marist Brothers Parramatta (1984–2004)

Chamberlains Law Firm is currently assisting in investigations related to serious allegations of abuse at Marist Brothers High School in...

Read more about Your Story Matters: Witnesses Sought in Historical Abuse Case Marist Brothers Parramatta (1984–2004)
Close-up of hands wrapping a bandage around an arm, with one person wearing an orange safety vest — representing first aid, emergency response, workplace safety, and injury care.

Injury & Compensation

How Do You Prove Lost Income in a Personal Injury Claim

When you are involved in a personal injury claim, it is important to understand what economic loss & damages mean....

Read more about How Do You Prove Lost Income in a Personal Injury Claim

I’ve received a National Redress payment, can I still receive more compensation?

What Is the National Redress Scheme? We often receive queries from clients who have received a payment from the National...

Read more about I’ve received a National Redress payment, can I still receive more compensation?

Abuse Compensation Claims

How does compensation for historic sexual abuse work?

What Options Do Survivors Have to Reopen Historic Child Sexual Abuse Settlements? Survivors of historic child sexual abuse have the...

Read more about How does compensation for historic sexual abuse work?