Motor Accident Compensation in Queensland: Part 5 – Resolving Claims and Disputes Under the MAI Act
This article continues our series on motor accident compensation in Queensland. You can read about the specific features of the Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 (“MAI Act”) in part 4 found here.
Dispute Resolution Processes
The MAI Act establishes a structured pre-court claims and dispute resolution system for motor accident injury claims in Queensland. While it does not replicate New South Wales’ Dispute Resolution Service (DRS), it creates an extensive statutory framework for the management, assessment and resolution of claims. All disputes arising under the MAI Act follow the pre-court procedures in Chapter 2, which must be completed before litigation can be commenced.
If a claimant is dissatisfied with an insurer’s decision relating to liability, quantum, treatment, rehabilitation, or the assessment of economic loss, an internal review may be sought from the insurer. If the claimant remains dissatisfied, the matter proceeds through the MAI Act’s compulsory conference regime. Queensland requires strict compliance with the Notice of Accident Claim (NOAC) and the subsequent exchange of information before a claim may progress.
The MAI Act provides access to funded legal assistance under certain circumstances, particularly for claimants whose claims have been denied or where liability is contested. These schemes are administered through MAIC and participating legal service providers.
Definition of “Earner”
The MAI Act does not contain a statutory definition of “earner” as appears in the MAIA. Instead, employment status is assessed in accordance with common law principles relevant to determining:
- past economic loss
- future economic loss
- loss of earning capacity
In Queensland:
- employment in the period before the accident
- established work history
- business or contract arrangements
- acceptance into employment before the accident
are all relevant to determining the claimant’s economic loss entitlements under the MAI Act.
MAIC and the Assessment of Liability for Damages
Once a claim for damages is made, the matter proceeds through the mandatory pre-court steps under the MAI Act, including exchange of information, medical examinations, and a compulsory conference. This is the primary statutory dispute resolution mechanism in Queensland. There is no equivalent of a binding DRS certificate.
An insurer’s denial of liability does not prevent a claimant progressing through the statutory process. Liability is ultimately resolved:
- at compulsory conference
- by mandatory final offers
- or in the District or Supreme Court if litigation follows
The insurer may face cost consequences in court proceedings depending on the final offers exchanged under s51C and s51D of the MAI Act.
Restrictions on Medico-Legal Evidence
The MAI Act regulates medical evidence through:
- ss45 – 50 (Medical Examinations)
- the Medical Assessment Tribunal (MAT) under the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003, where relevant
- procedural requirements imposed by the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR)
Queensland does not use a NSW-style “authorised practitioner” list, but insurers may require a claimant to attend independent medical examinations. Courts may appoint experts or direct joint medico-legal reports.
Evidence must comply with:
- the Evidence Act 1977 (Qld)
- the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld)
- the Expert Evidence Practice Direction (Supreme Court of Queensland)
Regulation of Costs
Costs in Queensland CTP matters are regulated through:
- the MAI Act
- the Supreme Court scale
- cost-limiting principles for claims below certain thresholds
Unlike NSW, Queensland does not cap costs through a statutory schedule tied to impairment categories. However, costs must remain proportionate to the claim and may be scrutinised during litigation.
Key Time Limits and Procedural Requirements under the MAI Act
Although Queensland does not follow the MAIA framework, it imposes detailed statutory obligations. Some of the most relevant include:
Notice of Accident Claim Form (NOAC)
- Must be given to the insurer within 9 months of the accident, or within 1 month of instructing a lawyer (s37).
- Insurer must confirm compliance or request further information within 14 days (s39).
Rehabilitation obligations
Under s51B MAI Act, insurers must provide reasonable and appropriate rehabilitation, and must respond to rehabilitation requests within 10 business days.
Compulsory Medical Examination
Insurers may require claimants to attend medical examinations under s45.
Compulsory Conference (s51A MAI Act)
Before court proceedings, parties must attend a compulsory conference.
The conference requires:
- full exchange of relevant medical and financial documentation
- meaningful participation by parties with authority to settle
- good faith negotiations
Mandatory Final Offers (MFOs)
If the claim does not settle at conference, each party must make a mandatory final offer (MFO).
Cost consequences attach to rejecting a reasonable MFO (s51C–51D).
Time limits for court proceedings
- Proceedings must be commenced within the limitation period of 3 years
- Proceedings cannot commence until the pre-court procedures are completed unless excused by the court
Internal insurer review
Although not identical to NSW, insurers typically conduct reviews of liability or rehabilitation decisions upon request. There is no statutory timeframe equivalent to MAIA s7.9, but insurers must act reasonably and respond promptly.
Comment
While Queensland’s MAI Act does not replicate the NSW DRS system, it introduces its own structured approach to resolving disputes. Key practical challenges include:
- the broad discretion afforded to insurers in rehabilitation decisions
- the significant reliance on medico-legal evidence, often requiring multiple assessments
- the potential for disputes regarding compliance with NOAC requirements
- substantial consequences arising from mandatory final offers
- the interaction between the MAI Act and the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 for multi-tortfeasor claims
The compulsory conference and final offer regime generally promote early resolution, although complex liability disputes may still require judicial intervention.
Read more about Motor Accident Compensation in Queensland in part 6 of the series, “Medical Assessment Processes”.
If you have any questions regarding motor accident compensation in NSW, please do not hesitate to contact Gary Patterson, Special Counsel & Associate Director, on (02) 9264 9111.




