Opens in a new tab

Motor Accident Compensation in Western Australia: Part 4 – Key Features of the WA Fault-Based Scheme

Written by Haidar Saab

Reviewed by

Written by Haidar Saab

Reviewed by

3 min read
Published: January 20, 2020
Page Content
Page Content

This article continues our series on motor accident compensation in Western Australia. You can read about the procedural requirements of the motor accident compensation scheme in part 3.

The WA CTP Scheme Framework

Western Australia has a very different system for motor accident injury claims. The WA scheme operates primarily as a fault-based model, providing common law damages for injured road users where negligence is established. There is no statutory benefits scheme equivalent to the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 (MAIA). For a detailed examination of the WA system, it is necessary to refer to the Motor Vehicle (Third Party Insurance) Act 1943 (WA), associated Regulations, and the Insurance Commission of Western Australia (ICWA) Claims Guidelines. The WA system does not adopt a hybrid statutory-benefits structure and continues to rely upon traditional common law principles.

Access to Treatment and Rehabilitation

Under the WA scheme, treatment and rehabilitation expenses are recovered as part of common law damages. In contrast to NSW, there are:

  • no automatic statutory benefits for income replacement
  • no 26-week no-fault entitlement period
  • no statutory obligation for an insurer to fund early treatment
    Entitlement to recover medical and rehabilitation expenses depends upon proving legal fault. ICWA may choose to fund treatment during the claims process, but this is administrative discretion and not a legislative entitlement. Contributory negligence reduces damages in accordance with established common law principles.

No “Minor Injury” Threshold and No Statutory Benefit Limits

Unlike NSW, Western Australia has no statutory “minor injury” threshold. In WA:

  • there is no statutory definition of “minor injury”
  • there is no six-month cap on statutory benefits
  • there are no statutory limits on eligibility for non-economic loss based on impairment
    Permanent impairment assessment occurs through medical evidence but is not tied to legislated impairment thresholds. As WA operates a pure fault-based system, injured persons are not restricted to statutory benefits.

No Restrictions on Gratuitous Care

Western Australia permits the recovery of gratuitous care and domestic assistance under traditional common law principles, including:

  • Griffiths v Kerkemeyer – damages for gratuitous care provided to a claimant
  • Sullivan v Gordon – damages for the loss of capacity to provide services to dependants
    These heads of damage continue to apply without statutory limitation.

Common Law Damages

Common law damages remain the foundation of the WA motor accident scheme. A claimant may recover:

  • non-economic loss (pain, suffering and loss of amenities)
  • past and future economic loss
  • loss of earning capacity
  • medical, rehabilitation and treatment expenses
  • domestic assistance and care (commercial or gratuitous)
  • loss of superannuation
  • out-of-pocket expenses
    There are no statutory minimum impairment thresholds for non-economic loss, and no MAIA-equivalent restrictions on when a damages claim may be commenced or settled.

Assessment of Medical Issues

Medical and treatment issues in WA are determined through medico-legal evidence. There is:

  • no Medical Assessment Service (MAS)
  • no statutory medical panels
  • no legislated limits on additional assessments
    Causation, impairment, treatment needs, capacity for work and long-term care requirements are determined by expert medical assessments and, where necessary, judicial decision-making by the District Court or Supreme Court of Western Australia.

Catastrophic Injuries Support Scheme

Western Australia operates a Catastrophic Injuries Support (CIS) Scheme under the Motor Vehicle (Catastrophic Injuries) Act 2016 (WA). This provides lifetime treatment, care and support to people catastrophically injured in motor vehicle accidents in WA. The scheme covers:

  • traumatic brain injury
  • spinal cord injury
  • multiple amputations
  • severe burns
  • permanent blindness
    Participation affects the damages recoverable at common law, as treatment and care provided by the CIS Scheme are not compensable again as damages.

Internal Review and Dispute Resolution

WA does not have the statutory internal review processes found in NSW. Instead, disputes are resolved through:

  • direct negotiation with ICWA
  • informal settlement discussions
  • pre-trial conferences under court rules
  • proceedings in the District Court or Supreme Court of Western Australia
    Claims proceed according to the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) and the District Court Rules 2005 (WA).

Read more about Motor Accident Compensation in Western Australia in part 5 of the series, “Dispute Resolution Procedures”, available here.

If you have any questions regarding motor accident compensation in NSW, please contact Gary Patterson, Special Counsel & Associate Director, on (02) 9264 9111.

Related articles

Motor Accident Compensation in Queensland: Part 4 – Key Features of the MAI Act (Qld) Scheme

This article continues our series on motor accident compensation. You can read about the procedural requirements of the scheme in...

Read more about Motor Accident Compensation in Queensland: Part 4 – Key Features of the MAI Act (Qld) Scheme

Motor Accident Compensation in the ACT: Part 4 – Core Characteristics of the ACT Common Law Model

This article continues our series on motor accident compensation in the ACT. You can read about the procedural requirements of...

Read more about Motor Accident Compensation in the ACT: Part 4 – Core Characteristics of the ACT Common Law Model

Motor Accident Compensation in NSW: Part 4- Specific Features of the MAIA

Motor Accident Compensation in NSW: Part 4 - Specific Features of the MAIA This article continues our series on motor...

Read more about Motor Accident Compensation in NSW: Part 4- Specific Features of the MAIA

Legal Professional Privilege Over Company Documents in Liquidation

An important function of the Courts is to determine which documents can and cannot be used as evidence in a...

Read more about Legal Professional Privilege Over Company Documents in Liquidation