Queensland Employers Hit With Major Penalties for WHS Breaches
Queensland courts continue to impose significant penalties on employers for failing to protect workers from obvious and foreseeable risks.
In Wilmar Sugar Pty Ltd v Blackwood [2018] QCA 138, an employee suffered fatal crush injuries while performing maintenance work at a sugar mill. The regulator alleged that Wilmar Sugar failed to ensure, so far as reasonably practicable, the health and safety of the worker, particularly regarding plant isolation and safe systems of work. The Court of Appeal found that the regulator’s decision to prosecute was reasonable, highlighting the seriousness of the breaches and the clear foreseeability of the risk. The proceedings demonstrated the obligation of PCBUs to implement robust safety controls in high-risk industrial environments.
In Williamson v Betterlay Brick and Block Laying Pty Ltd (2020) 3 QR 594, a brick wall collapsed during construction, exposing workers to a serious risk of death or serious injury. The company was initially acquitted, however, the Court of Appeal reinstated the conviction and fine, finding that the PCBU failed to ensure, so far as reasonably practicable, the health and safety of persons on site. The inadequate supervision and lack of structural support measures were central to the breach.
These cases emphasise that Queensland courts take a strict approach to failures that expose workers to fatal or serious risks.
Work Health & Safety Legislation
Queensland operates under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld).
s 19: Primary duty of care
PCBUs must ensure, so far as reasonably practicable, the health and safety of:
- their workers
- workers influenced or directed by them
- other persons affected by the work
s 18: Reasonably practicable
Factors include:
- Likelihood of the risk
- Degree of harm
- What the PCBU knows or ought to know
- Availability and suitability of controls
- Cost (unless grossly disproportionate)
Penalties Under the WHS Act (Qld)
Penalty units in Queensland for 2022–2023 are also $143.75 per unit.
For s 31 — Reckless conduct:
- Individual: 3,000 units = $431,250
- Officer: 6,000 units = $862,500
- Body corporate: 30,000 units = $4,312,500
How We Can Help
Employers must maintain effective WHS systems, including:
- Safe systems of work
- Proper plant isolation procedures
- Competent supervision
- Adequate training
The Chamberlains Employment & Workplace Law Team provides:
- WHS audits
- Legal compliance reviews
- Emergency advice following serious incidents
Get started today and reach out to our team for assistance with your matter.

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Antonia Tahhan of our Workplace Team on 02 6188 3600




