Opens in a new tab

Smoking Gun – Employees’ Dismissal Upheld for Stolen Cigarettes

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: July 17, 2019
Page Content
Page Content

A recent decision by the Fair Work Commission (FWC) has outlined the evidentiary burden to be met by employers when dismissing employees for misconduct. The FWC upheld the dismissal of two employees involved in the theft of cigarettes from a Virgin Australia flight’s freight load.

An internal investigation was conducted by Virgin after it was suspected that one of their employees, a non-smoker, had stolen two packets of cigarettes and given them to a colleague. The investigation discovered the colleague had offered the cigarettes to two other employees during a break, revealing to them that the other employee had taken them from the freight load. The two other employees declined the offer, and one later reported the exchange to the duty manager.

Virgin followed up on the packages which were to be sent from Sydney to Cairns and found two packs of cigarettes to be missing. The manager on site indicated Virgin’s process meant it was likely the cigarettes were stolen from the freight hold of the aircraft when it was being loaded at Sydney Airport.

The employees were suspended on full pay by Virgin to allow for an investigation. Despite a lack of CCTV footage, Virgin came to the conclusion two employees had stolen and received the cigarettes. They were both summarily dismissed for serious misconduct.
On the day of dismissal, the smoker made a post on social media which claimed that “[Virgin] HAVE FIRED ME TODAY AND HAVE NOT PROVIDED ME WITH ANY EVIDENCE.”

Contrary to this view, FWC Deputy President Peter Sams found that Virgin Australia had “an overwhelming evidentiary foundation to conclude, on the balance of probabilities” that the two employees were responsible for the theft of the cigarettes.
Deputy President Sams stated went on to state that “Virgin’s evidentiary case provided a sound, logical and rational foundation for the Commission, to be satisfied the denials of involvement in the theft, cannot be accepted.”

A key factor considered by the FWC was the dishonesty of the employees attempting to cover up the theft. The FWC outlined that the value of the items stolen were irrelevant when placed against the deceit of denying their conduct. This resulted in the employment relationship breaking down beyond repair. This breakdown underpinned the decision from the FWC to uphold the dismissal.

This matter highlights the importance of thorough processes when terminating employees contracts. If looking to dismiss an employee for misconduct, it is critical the employer has an evidentiary basis to lean upon. Accordingly, investigations and proper legal advice is integral.

If you are seeking advice in relation to an unfair dismissal claim, please call Angela Backhouse on (02) 6188 3600.

Related articles

Using ™ and ® – What are the Differences?

What is a trade mark and how are they signified? You have probably seen superscript symbols above famous logos and...

Read more about Using ™ and ® – What are the Differences?

Big Enough Fish: Changes to Financial Thresholds for Reporting Requirements for Proprietary Companies

The Treasury has recently implemented amendments to the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) (under the Corporations Act 2001) regarding the reporting...

Read more about Big Enough Fish: Changes to Financial Thresholds for Reporting Requirements for Proprietary Companies

Corporate & Commercial Law

Fairness in Franchising and the Government’s New Special Taskforce

Earlier this year in March, the Australian Parliamentary Joint Committee on Corporations and Financial Services handed down its 369-page report...

Read more about Fairness in Franchising and the Government’s New Special Taskforce

“The Golden Bowl is Broken”: Bob Hawke & the Dispute over his Will

Australia's longest-serving prime minister passed away on May 16 at the age of 89. Now, a few months after the...

Read more about “The Golden Bowl is Broken”: Bob Hawke & the Dispute over his Will