Opens in a new tab

The Proceedings Were Dismissed, So Pay My Costs!

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

1 min read
Published: October 6, 2021
Legal Topics
Litigation & Dispute Resolution
Page Content
Page Content

In the recent decision of Josey v InvestaFox Pty Limited [2021] NSWSC 827, the Supreme Court of New South Wales consider the legal costs implications when legal proceedings are dismissed.

P commenced legal proceedings seeking specific performance of a deed that saw D grant P a drainage easement. Shortly afterwards, the proceedings were dismissed by agreement.

When proceedings are dismissed normally the plaintiff will pay the defendant’s legal costs, unless the Court says otherwise: Uniform Civil Procedure Rule r42.20.

P said D had engaged in unreasonable delay in relation to the deed, forcing P to commence proceedings.

D said the deed had not been entered into properly before the proceedings were commenced.

There was a degree of delay of delay and disorganisation about entering into the deed, and confusion about when the counterparts were executed.

There was some suggestion that D might have engaged in unreasonable delay, but there was also a complaint that it took P the best part of a year to pay an $800 invoice required by the deed.

Due to the delay in progressing the matter, the Court found it was not unreasonable for P to have commenced proceedings.

However, the Court ordered each party to pay its own costs.

This judgment confirms that a plaintiff may stand disappointed if it relies too heavily on r42.20 to carry the day.

 

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Chamberlains and talk to our dispute resolution team today.

If you have any questions or concerns, please contact James d’Apice of our Litigation & Dispute Resolution Team on 02 9264 9111

Related articles

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

You fired me just to get my Co’s shares at a discount!

In the recent decision of Yelland v Plus Architecture [2021] VSC 416 the Supreme Court of Victoria considered whether a...

Read more about You fired me just to get my Co’s shares at a discount!

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

Just Transfer The Shares To Me!

In the recent decision of Alon Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 1021, the Supreme Court of New South Wales considered the...

Read more about Just Transfer The Shares To Me!

A Look at Fixed Costs Orders: NSW Courts

Discretion under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) The power of courts in NSW to award costs to litigants is...

Read more about A Look at Fixed Costs Orders: NSW Courts

“The Company Paid Too Much For That Helicopter!”

In the decision of Global Pacific Aerospace Pty Limited [2012] VSC 291, The Supreme Court of Victoria considered a dispute...

Read more about “The Company Paid Too Much For That Helicopter!”