Opens in a new tab

Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in Queensland?

Written by Michael
Terry-Whitall

Reviewed by

Written by Michael
Terry-Whitall

Reviewed by

4 min read
Published: November 29, 2022
Legal Topics
Building & Construction Law
Page Content
Page Content

Will the Court Order Security for Costs in Queensland? Key Tests for Success

The general premise of advancing a security for costs application in Queensland under Chapter 17 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (“UCPR (Qld)”) is to minimise the risk that a defendant will suffer financial loss where an impecunious plaintiff is ultimately unsuccessful and cannot satisfy an adverse costs order. A defendant may, early in the litigation process, apply for an order requiring the plaintiff to provide security (usually a payment into Court or bank guarantee) to safeguard the potential recovery of costs.

While such applications can be seen as limiting access to justice, the Court engages in a balancing exercise. It must ensure that a defendant is properly protected, without unjustly stifling a plaintiff who may have a legitimate claim but limited financial resources.

The defendant must establish that the statutory grounds for security exist, and then persuade the Court that, in its discretion, security is appropriate in all the circumstances.

The Legal Framework: Rules 670 – 673 UCPR (Qld)

Rule 670: Court’s Power to Order Security

Rule 670 sets out that, on a defendant’s application, the Court may order security for costs “as appropriate”, subject to the requirements in rules 671 and 672.

Rule 671: Prerequisites for Ordering Security

At least one of the following must be satisfied before the Court’s power is enlivened:

  • The plaintiff is a corporation and there is reason to believe it will not be able to pay the defendant’s costs if ordered to do so.
  • The plaintiff is suing for the benefit of another person and there is reason to believe it will be unable to pay costs.
  • The plaintiff’s address is not stated or misstated in the originating process (unless not intended to deceive).
  • The plaintiff has changed address since commencement in circumstances suggesting avoidance of the proceeding.
  • The plaintiff is ordinarily resident outside Australia.
  • The plaintiff is, or is about to become, ordinarily resident outside Australia and has insufficient property of a permanent nature available for enforcement.
  • An Act authorises the making of the order.
  • The justice of the case requires the making of the order.

Evidence such as financial statements, ASIC searches, or proof of overseas residence is commonly required to satisfy rule 671.

Rule 672: Discretionary Factors

Once a ground in r 671 is met, the Court then considers a range of discretionary factors, including:

  • the means of those standing behind the proceeding;
  • the prospects of success or merits of the proceeding;
  • the genuineness of the claim;
  • whether the plaintiff’s impecuniosity is attributable to the defendant;
  • whether the plaintiff is effectively in the position of a defendant;
  • whether an order would be oppressive or stifle the proceeding;
  • whether the matter involves public importance;
  • any admissions or payments into court;
  • delay in bringing the proceeding;
  • whether costs orders would be enforceable within Queensland;
  • the overall costs of the proceeding.

These factors mirror the balancing exercise undertaken in NSW but are expressly codified in r 672.

Rule 673: Form, Timing and Consequences

If security is ordered:

  • it must be given in the form, time, and on conditions the Court directs; and
  • failure to provide security may result in the proceeding being stayed or dismissed.

The Two-Stage Test in QLD

Security for costs applications in Queensland follow a clear two-step analysis:

  1. Threshold Test – Rule 671
    The defendant must establish, with evidence, that at least one prerequisite applies.
  2. Discretion – Rule 672
    Once the threshold is met, the Court weighs all relevant considerations.
    The plaintiff bears the onus of showing why security should not be ordered or should be reduced.

The Leading Case: Zhao v CN-AU Capital Pty Ltd [2025] QSC 290

In Zhao, the Supreme Court of Queensland considered applications for security under rr 671–672. Key findings included:

  • The Court accepted that rule 671 was satisfied, enlivening the jurisdiction to order security.
  • However, security was refused due to the defensive nature of the proceedings, credibility of the respondents’ claims, and the defendant’s unexplained delay in bringing the application.
  • The Court also held that strong merits and the genuine nature of the claim could outweigh concerns about enforceability abroad.

The case reinforces that even where r 671 is met, the Court will carefully apply r 672 to ensure that ordering security does not unfairly hinder legitimate litigation.

A Pure Discretion Based on Justice

Ultimately, even where the rule 671 threshold is satisfied, the Court retains a broad discretion. The question is always:

What order best serves justice in the particular circumstances of the case?

Courts consistently warn that security for costs should not be used oppressively, nor to extinguish a genuine claim. Equally, defendants should not be exposed to the real risk of unrecoverable legal costs.

What order best serves justice in the circumstances of the particular case?

This requires weighing the defendant’s legitimate interest in cost protection against the plaintiff’s right to pursue their claim without unfair hindrance.

If you have any questions about website terms and conditions, please contact Michael Terry-Whitall of our Building & Construction Law Team on 02 9264 9111

Related articles

Building & Construction Law

How to Deal With Encroaching Buildings

Encroachment Generally Encroachment can be a frustrating issue for landowners. It occurs where an adjacent dwelling has been constructed to...

Read more about How to Deal With Encroaching Buildings

Building & Construction Law

Pleading Complicated Construction Matters as Global Claims

Pleading complicated construction matters as global claims: a look at the decision in John Holland Construction & Engineering Pty Ltd v...

Read more about Pleading Complicated Construction Matters as Global Claims

Building & Construction Law

Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in ACT?

Security for Costs in the ACT: How Courts Decide and What You Must Show The purpose of a security for...

Read more about Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in ACT?

Building & Construction Law

Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in WA?

Applying for Security for Costs in WA: Thresholds, Discretion and Key Cases Applications for security for costs in Western Australia...

Read more about Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in WA?