Opens in a new tab

You’ve got to pay fair value. No minority discount!

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: January 29, 2021
Legal Topics
Corporate & Commercial Law
Page Content
Page Content

When thinking about the value of a minority shareholder’s shares, it is sometimes said that a “minority discount” applies. This price reduction may reflect the inability of a minority to influence the company, or perhaps the undesirability of being in business with the majority shareholder.

In a recent decision of the Victorian Supreme Court, Joint v Program IT Pty Limited & Ors [2020] VSC 867, the Court considered the right price for the sale of the minority shareholder’s shares, including whether the discount applied.

A minority shareholder recently applied to the Court for orders requiring the majority shareholder to by their shares.

All parties agreed that a share purchase was best. What was not agreed upon was the price. The majority shareholder said that a minority discount should apply.

The law is clear in this area: if there has been oppressive conduct, there will be no minority discount.

The facts in the matter were complex.

For many years, the minority shareholder had owned their shares and had previously won an oppression suit, requiring another party to buy them. However, the would-be buyer became insolvent, and that sale fell through.

Later, a company director became the majority shareholder and brought the company back “into the black”; doing hard work in the years 2009 to 2012 to improve the company’s financial performance.

From this time, that director was paid substantial fees.

In 2015 that directed transferred their shares to the current majority shareholder and began to cause them also to be paid fees, and for both to be paid for travel expenses. Later, in 2020, the director caused the appointment of administrators after the legal proceedings had been commenced.

The Court found the payment of post-2012 fees, payment of travel expenses, and appointment of administrators was oppressive and that the majority shareholder would have to pay “full whack” for the shares, with no minority discount.

When thinking about a company’s shares or structuring your affairs, it is essential to get expert advice to avoid the problematic situation that the minority shareholder found themselves in, described above.

 

If you have any legal questions about commercial and corporate law, reach out to our specialists at Chamberlains Law Firm!

 

Interested in learning more on Corporate & Commercial Law? 

Click our recent articles below to find out more:

Principles To Remember When Interpreting Terms Of Commercial Contracts

What Do You Do if You Lose a Trust Deed?

Selling Your Business? Make it a “going concern” please.

If you have any questions or concerns, please contact James d’Apice on 02 9264 9111

Related articles

Corporate & Commercial Law

Corporate Oppression – The Importance of Shareholder Agreements

The sometimes complex area of corporate oppression is easily misunderstood. Occasionally a shareholder will be disappointed with the way a...

Read more about Corporate Oppression – The Importance of Shareholder Agreements

Corporate & Commercial Law

How To Build A Business

Starting a new business can be a daunting time. This guide lists 6 legal considerations you should consider when launching...

Read more about How To Build A Business

Corporate & Commercial Law

Compulsory Buy-Out Instead of Winding Up

The 2020 case of Snell v Glatis (Snell v Glatis (No 2) [2020] NSWCA 166), where Chamberlains Law Firm represented the...

Read more about Compulsory Buy-Out Instead of Winding Up

Let’s Get Our Company to Buy Some Land. I’ll Have Some & You Can Have… None?

In the recent decision of Fuller v Albert [2021] NSWCA 88, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an example of...

Read more about Let’s Get Our Company to Buy Some Land. I’ll Have Some & You Can Have… None?