Opens in a new tab

Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in ACT?

Written by Michael
Terry-Whitall

Reviewed by

Written by Michael
Terry-Whitall

Reviewed by

3 min read
Published: November 29, 2022
Legal Topics
Building & Construction Law
Page Content
Page Content

Security for Costs in the ACT: How Courts Decide and What You Must Show

The purpose of a security for costs application in the Australian Capital Territory is to reduce the risk that a defendant will be left unable to recover its legal costs if an impecunious plaintiff is ultimately unsuccessful. Under the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), a defendant may apply early in the litigation process for an order requiring the plaintiff to provide security, usually via a payment into court or another acceptable form of guarantee.

Although such applications protect defendants from unrecoverable costs, they must also be weighed against a plaintiff’s right to pursue a claim. As in other jurisdictions, the ACT courts conduct a careful balancing exercise to ensure that ordering security does not unjustly stifle a genuine cause of action.

The Legal Framework: Rules 1900–1902 CPR (ACT)

Rule 1900: Evidentiary Requirements

An application must be supported by an affidavit, setting out the factual basis and the grounds relied on for security. This includes evidence of the plaintiff’s financial position, residence, supporting parties, prospects, and any other material relevant to the statutory tests.

Rule 1901: Threshold Circumstances

Before the Court can consider discretion, at least one ground in r 1901 must be established:

  • The plaintiff is a corporation and there is reason to believe it will be unable to pay the defendant’s costs if ordered.
  • The plaintiff is ordinarily resident outside Australia or is about to leave Australia and has insufficient fixed and permanent property within the jurisdiction to satisfy a costs order.
  • The justice of the case requires that security be ordered.

If one of these criteria is met, the jurisdiction to order security is enlivened.

Rule 1902: Discretionary Factors

Once the threshold is satisfied, the Court turns to a broad range of discretionary considerations, including:

  • the financial means of those standing behind the litigation;
  • the merits or prospects of success;
  • the genuineness of the proceeding;
  • whether the plaintiff’s impecuniosity was caused by the defendant;
  • whether the plaintiff is effectively in the position of a defendant;
  • whether the order would be oppressive or stifle the proceeding;
  • whether the matter concerns public importance;
  • any admissions or payments into court;
  • delay in commencing the proceeding;
  • enforceability of a costs order;
  • the estimated costs of the proceeding.

The discretion is broad and requires the Court to evaluate what outcome best serves justice in the circumstances.

Relevant Cases demonstrating orders relating to security of costs:

ACT courts have developed a consistent approach to applying the rules:

Atarashii Stone Pty Ltd v Granite Transformations (No 3) [2017] ACTSC 139; [2017] ACTSC 198

Security of $50,000 was ordered after the Court examined the plaintiff’s financial position and the likely costs of the proceeding. The case demonstrates that the Court may rely on inherent jurisdiction where the CPR does not expressly apply.

Benjamin v GB Franchising Australia Pty Ltd [2008] ACTCA 11

The Court confirmed that the default position is that no security is payable unless the applicant establishes grounds for it. Impecuniosity alone is relevant but not conclusive. Each case must be assessed on its own facts.

Twining v Curtis [2014] ACTCA 19

Security of $25,000 was ordered where the respondent was impecunious and the appeal lacked prospects. Delay in bringing the application was not sufficient to defeat it.

 

As in other jurisdictions, even if the prerequisites for security are met, the ACT Court retains a broad discretion. The ultimate question is always:

Does ordering security best achieve justice between the parties?

The Court will not allow security to be used oppressively, nor permit a defendant to exploit the process to extinguish a legitimate claim. Conversely, it will not require a defendant to bear the real risk of unrecoverable costs where the plaintiff cannot meet an adverse order.

If you have any questions about website terms and conditions, please contact Michael Terry-Whitall of our Building & Construction Law Team on 02 9264 9111

Related articles

Building & Construction Law

Pleading Complicated Construction Matters as Global Claims

Pleading complicated construction matters as global claims: a look at the decision in John Holland Construction & Engineering Pty Ltd v...

Read more about Pleading Complicated Construction Matters as Global Claims

Building & Construction Law

Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in Queensland?

Will the Court Order Security for Costs in Queensland? Key Tests for Success The general premise of advancing a security...

Read more about Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in Queensland?

Building & Construction Law

Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in WA?

Applying for Security for Costs in WA: Thresholds, Discretion and Key Cases Applications for security for costs in Western Australia...

Read more about Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in WA?

Building & Construction Law

Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in NSW?

Security for Costs in NSW: When Will the Court Order It Against Your Opponent? The general premise of advancing a...

Read more about Will I be Successful in a Security of Costs Application Against my Opponent in NSW?