Opens in a new tab

Can an Insurer Rely on Non-Disclosure of a Matter it Already Knew?

Written by Chamberlains

Written by Chamberlains

2 min read
Published: September 2, 2021
Legal Topics
Insurance Law
Page Content
Page Content

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) recently determined a dispute between Auto & General Services Pty Ltd (Auto & General) and their insured, who made a claim for a motor vehicle incident. The AFCA determined whether an insurer could reject a claim on the basis of non-disclosure of a criminal conviction in circumstances where they had knowledge of the criminal conviction.

Background

Auto & General rejected their insured’s claim due to the non-disclosure of a previous criminal conviction. The insured argued that there was no non-disclosure as the insured had previously had a phone conversation with the insurer regarding a separate claim, where they had disclosed the criminal conviction.

Determination

The AFCA found that there was no non-disclosure by the insured because they had disclosed the criminal conviction on a previous occasion. Auto & General was already aware of the insured’s criminal conviction due to a disclosure made in the course of a previous claim. Section 21(2)(c) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) (the Act) provides that the duty of disclosure does not require disclosure of a matter that the insurer knows or ought to know. As such, it was found that Auto & General knew of the criminal conviction and could not reject the insured’s claim on the basis of non-disclosure.

However, the AFCA found that there had been misrepresentation by the insured when the insured had answered “no” when applying for a policy and was asked if there were any relevant criminal offences.

Section 28(3) of the Act entitles the insurer to reduce their liability to the position they would have been in had the misrepresentation not been made. The insurer argued that had the insured not made the misrepresentation, they would not have provided the policy.

The AFCA found in favour of Auto & General, holding that they were entitled to reject the claim for misrepresentation.

Implications of this decision

It is important to understand your obligations under an insurance policy and how non-disclosure and misrepresentation may affect your claim outcome. Even if your insurer was previously made aware of a matter you are required to disclosure, you should continue to be truthful and transparent about matters which may affect your policy.

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Chamberlains and talk to one of our insurance law experts today.

If you have any questions or concerns please contact Stirling Owen of our Insurance Team on 02 6188 3600

Related articles

Insurance Law

Don’t get Capped Out of Your Costs in the General Division of the Local Court NSW

In Clutch & Brake Australia Pty Ltd v Khamis [2018] NSWSC 777 (Clutch), the Court considered the implications of Part...

Read more about Don’t get Capped Out of Your Costs in the General Division of the Local Court NSW

Insurance Law

Second COVID-19 Business Interruption Insurance Test Case Given the Green Light

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) have approved the commencement of a second COVID-19 business interruption test case by the...

Read more about Second COVID-19 Business Interruption Insurance Test Case Given the Green Light

What to Do If You’ve Been in a Car Accident

Being involved in a car accident can be a shocking and frightening experience and it may be difficult to remember...

Read more about What to Do If You’ve Been in a Car Accident

Insurance Law

If My Luxury Car Is Damaged, Am I Entitled To A Luxury Replacement Car?

On 18 June 2020, the NSW Court of Appeal handed down its decision in the matter of Lee v Strelnicks;...

Read more about If My Luxury Car Is Damaged, Am I Entitled To A Luxury Replacement Car?